In the wake of the loss of the Cambridge Whistleblowing Tribunal, and with the Grace impending, the University of Cambridge has announced the membership of the committee tasked with examining its human resources (HR) processes.
The committee is chaired by Laura Whyte, with Cindy Butts, Mary Curnock Cook, Helen Fairfoul and Colin Riordan as members. We take a critical look at their records.
Laura Whyte
Laura Whyte is a senior HR and governance professional. She spent a decade on the John Lewis Management Board, initially as Registrar and subsequently as HR Director. As Registrar, her role was intended to provide the Board with an objective assessment of whether employees were appropriately supported and whether their views were being reflected in decision-making.
She is the author of HMRC’s 2019 Respect at Work review. It was commissioned specifically to examine the gap between HMRC’s stated values and employées’ experience.
“My report has sought to assess the gap between HMRC’s stated ambitions and the reality on the ground. I’ve identified a range of areas for HMRC to consider taking action, and I know from my conversations with HMRC’s leadership that they are committed to addressing this issue” (Laura Whyte)
This is plainly relevant to the matter in hand. Whyte examined the culture and systems of HMRC and found serious problems: employees lacked confidence in the grievance process and what the report called “low level poor behaviour” had become normalised. Her approach was reformist rather than adversarial. Her recommendations emphasised behavioural standards, better processes, mediation, reasonable adjustments, data and leadership responsibility. HMRC accepted all the recommendations.
HMRC subsequently introduced behavioural commitments and revised policies, but the existence of implementation activity doesn’t by itself establish that the underlying cultural problems were solved. HMRC’s subsequent annual reporting records the implementation, but not an independent assessment of their long-term effectiveness or a demonstration that the cultural problems identified by Whyte were successfully overcome.
She has spent much of her career operating within, and helping to govern, large organisations. There is an important distinction between repairing an organisation from within and holding an institution to account from outside it. The former focuses on improving processes, behaviour and governance; the latter requires asking more fundamental questions about power, responsibility, incentives and whether the institution’s own structures contributed to the problem.
Cindy Butts
Cindy Butts has worked in policing, criminal justice and public life, including at the Independent Police Complaints Commission. She chaired the Independent Commission for Equity in Cricket (ICEC). She was appointed Standing Advocate for the Independent Public Advocate in 2025 following parliamentary pre-appointment scrutiny.
ICEC examined racism, sexism, class discrimination and other forms of inequality throughout English and Welsh cricket. Its 2023 report concluded that discrimination was widespread and made 44 recommendations, including an unreserved apology from the ECB, as reported here by the BBC. The scale and nature of the findings demonstrated that Butts was prepared to subject a major institution to searching scrutiny, rather than confining the exercise to questions of individual behaviour or procedural compliance.
Butts was not afraid to be very critical of the institution that commissioned her review. She subsequently criticised the ECB over its failure to make the county talent pathway entirely free and publicly expressed disappointment when the ECB did not challenge Lord Botham’s attack on the ICEC report. These interventions are significant because they occurred after the principal report had been delivered and demonstrate a willingness to maintain public pressure on the institution that had commissioned the work.
The ICEC itself was established by the ECB. The commission therefore operated within an institutional structure in which the body ultimately responsible for the sport had commissioned the scrutiny of itself. Implementation ultimately depended upon the same institution that had been investigated. The subsequent parliamentary scrutiny of cricket illustrates how difficult it is to convert recommendations into structural change.
Butts’ background means she is strongly oriented towards victims, inequality, institutional accountability and public-interest advocacy. Of the five, she has the clearest demonstrated record of telling a commissioning institution things that it did not necessarily want to hear.
Independence is not simply a matter of whether an investigator is formally external to an organisation. It also concerns the intellectual and professional standpoint from which the organisation is examined. So, we are particularly impressed by the fact that Butts continued to challenge the commissioning institution publicly when she considered aspects of its response inadequate.
Mary Curnock Cook
Mary Curnock Cook is an independent education expert and former UCAS Chief Executive. She has held extensive non-executive positions across higher education, qualifications and education policy. Her career is deeply connected to the higher-education establishment.
She was UCAS Chief Executive from 2010–17 and has subsequently accumulated a portfolio of governance roles. She is currently a member of the University of Leicester Council and chairs its Audit and Assurance Committee; she also has roles connected with Pearson and many other education organisations.
She is clearly knowledgeable about the Higher Education sector. This raises an obvious question for a supposedly independent university review — how far can someone embedded in the governance networks of higher education provide any independent perspective?
There is an interesting episode from her UCAS career. Curnock Cook was a prominent critic of the practice of schools inflating predicted grades. Later, the issue of predicted grades became controversial when the Guardian exposed a policy at Sevenoaks School encouraging teachers to increase predictions for some students. In response to the revelation, Mary Curnock Cook noted that while it is understandable for schools to present their students in the most optimistic light, it was “embarrassing for Sevenoaks that deliberately overpredicting students’ grades is in writing in their guidelines“. In 2015, she also criticised independent schools for encouraging students into predictable elite career paths and argued that some private-school pupils were receiving a narrow educational experience, as noted here.
Her present activities are heavily concentrated in higher-education governance. She has the deepest network of the five within the education establishment: the government’s biography currently lists her as Chair of Dyson Institute and Pearson Education Ltd, NED of the London Interdisciplinary School and The Student Room, trustee of HEPI, and chair of an HE ed-tech group, in addition to her earlier UCAS career. She sits on the University of Leicester Council, which is ultimately responsible for the institution’s strategic direction and ensuring that its systems and procedures are fit for purpose. There have been many criticisms of the recent direction of the University of Leicester, especially with regard to its lacks of support for arts and humanities.
She’s an insider with considerable knowledge of how universities operate, but not a natural advocate for the perspective of staff challenging university management.
Helen Fairfoul
Helen Fairfoul was Chief Executive of the Universities and Colleges Employers Association (UCEA) from 2012–20. UCEA represents university employers in collective bargaining with trade unions. She subsequently became a governor at Northumbria University and a member of its Remuneration Committee.
UCEA is not a neutral body. It represents university employers in employment negotiations. That means that during a substantial period of her career, she was one of the most senior figures on the employers’ side of UK higher-education industrial relations.
During the major UCU disputes over pay, pensions, workload and casualisation, Fairfoul publicly represented the employers’ position. In 2019, UCU wrote directly to her as UCEA chief executive, arguing that UCEA’s proposals failed to address workload, precarious employment and gender pay gaps.
She also defended the use of casual and zero-hours arrangements in higher education. In evidence to Parliament, she argued that universities would generally need a casual element to their workforce and that zero-hours frameworks could be suitable in some circumstances.
UCEA’s position during the industrial disputes was explicitly that of the university employers. In 2019, Fairfoul was a signatory to an open letter from UCEA and Universities UK arguing that meeting UCU’s demands would divert unsustainable amounts of money from other university priorities. In January 2020, as industrial action continued, she defended the employers’ proposals, saying that UCEA had gone further than previously in putting forward sector-wide proposals.
Her professional identity is built around representing and advising university employers on employment relations. She is an unusual choice for a panel examining an institution in which staff may have allegations concerning employment practices, governance or culture.
Her current role at Northumbria University makes this even more controversial. She chairs its Finance and Resources Committee, a body with responsibility for significant institutional financial matters. There is a potential concern created by Fairfoul’s previous role representing university employers and her present university governance position. There has already been public criticism from university trade-union representatives of this combination of roles.
We regard Fairfoul as a poor choice for the panel. Her career has been unusually closely aligned with the interests of university employers. We doubt whether she can provide an independent perspective where the interests and experiences of university staff are central to the issues under examination.
Colin Riordan
Colin Riordan knows universities from the perspective of the Vice Chancellor and senior management. He was Vice-Chancellor of Cardiff University from 2012–23 and previously Vice-Chancellor of Essex. He has extensive sector-level governance experience and is now Secretary General and CEO of the Association of Commonwealth Universities.
His Cardiff tenure included major industrial disputes over pay and pensions. In early 2020, Cardiff University was in an industrial dispute with unions, with approximately 800 employees involved in strike action at the end of 2019.
Cardiff UCU was openly critical of Riordan’s position during the USS dispute, asking him to use his influence within Universities UK to support an enhanced offer to staff.
There was also a significant dispute over senior pay. Cardiff UCU reported in 2019 that Riordan attended the remuneration body that set his pay, although he was not himself a member of the remuneration committee. The union criticised his reported £298,000 remuneration package in 2018 against the background of job reductions and staff disputes.
Cardiff University is now in considerable financial crisis, as we have reported earlier. Most of the criticism has been directed towards the current Vice Chancellor, Wendy Larner, but most of the poor financial decisions were actually taken under her predecessor, Colin Riordan.
We therefore regard this as a very poor appointment. Riordan’s career has been overwhelmingly situated on the senior-management side of university power. His experience may give him extensive knowledge of how universities are run. However, he is closely associated with some of the most damaging aspects of University management over the last decades.
Overall Assessment
This committee is seriously unbalanced.
Many of its members are university management insiders.They may be independent of the organisation commissioning the review in the narrow sense, but several are deeply embedded in the institutional world being reviewed. This is particularly true of Curnock Cook, Fairfoul and Riordan. Their natural empathy is likely to be with the difficulties of running a large organisation with many staff, and with the management problems created by disputes involving those staff. Only Butts brings a particularly strong track record of challenging institutions from the outside.
Given the investigation was prompted by a damaging Employment Tribunal loss, the absence of an employment lawyer is absolutely astonishing.
There is also no obvious member whose principal career has been as a trade union official, or an academic, or a whistleblower or investigator specialising in institutional retaliation, or a student representative, or an independent journalist/investigative researcher specialising in universities, or an independent academic specialising in organisational abuse, institutional culture or power.
We would put the following question to Laura Whyte as chair:
Why does a review concerned with institutional culture and accountability require three people with substantial senior-management/sector-governance backgrounds, including a former national representative of university employers and a former university Vice-Chancellor, but no person whose principal professional experience has been representing university employees or investigating institutional retaliation against them?
The committee does not contain a single, obvious independent voice whose career has been principally spent representing university employées.
In our view, the appointments of Laura Whyte and Cindy Butts could be excellent as part of a more balanced committee. In the absence of that balance, the composition of this committee is completely unacceptable.
Question for painters and decorators.
Should gloss-over come before or after white-wash?
Are we decorating, or just trying to cover up the cracks? 😉
The bigger issue is the ToRs. For the Afzal investigation they have been narrowed so restrictively as to completely exclude the real issues – i.e. safeguarding for staff more broadly, role of legal services, or exposing the cynicism of hiring and promotions processes.
Agreed. We will look at ToR shortly, but this committee is pretty much unacceptable whatever the ToR.
Majority (3 out of 5) of university apparatchniks — nothing good can come out of this committee
Can someone remind me who approved this list? It is my understanding that it was the University Council. Was the decision unanimous?
Perhaps they could share the records of those discussions, if they exist? Or did they, like Ms Louise Akroyd, treat important meetings as “informal” and not even take notes?
More important than who approved the list is who drew up the list, and whether there were any conflicts of interest at that stage. I can imagine Council simply waiving it through but more important I think is the independence of the internal appointments procedure, given what we know about who has been involved in the various cases behind the scenes.
If you mean Baroness Sally Morgan, she is obviously conflicted, but she is as shameless as the Vice-Chancellor. Based on her public actions, I can imagine she was one of the first to approve that list. But, you know, it is “confidential.” 😉
Do we know that Sally Morgan is overseeing the investigations?
Formally the external appointments committee is Deborah Prentice, Heather Hancock, Daniela de Angelis, Ewa Marek, Jason Scott-Warren and Gaenor Bagley? Or did they establish an ad hoc committee specifically for the investigations? If the former then other than Ewa and Jason, they have similar backgrounds to the individuals they appointed, but it is disappointing not to have had more input from academics, civil society, unions or whistleblowers. Sally Morgan is on the Council so would be able to approve or deny, but it would be a terrible idea to have her involved directly. That is not so much from a governance perspective than a public relations angle as the Spectator and Telegraph would be on to it right away, not least of all given her formal role in the Arday appointment process.
Isn’t de Angelis a working academic?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniela_De_Angelis
Debbie at her best! Establishment protecting Establishment! Stasi investigating the KGB would be a good headline!
With regard to Curnock Cook and her role on the University of Leicester Council, it is only fair to point out that at least a couple of Employment Tribunals had less than flattering things to say about how that university handled its obligations as an employer. While I have no experience on a Council myself, I should have thought that was one of the things the governance structure would be keen to prevent, rather than finding out that the management they were overseeing were making these blunders in employment law after the fact in a tribunal judgement and less than flattering press coverage.
This is a very good point
Plenty of successful unfair dismissal claims against Leicester University
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/66ded5ad54a79f541f089249/Dr_A_M_D_Arcy_v_University_of_Leicester_2600044.2022_Amended_Judgment.pdf
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/65f17316981227a772f612f6/Dr_D_Harvie___Others_v_University_of_Leicester_2603036_2021_Final.pdf
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5f46790cd3bf7f5d7f263b6c/Mrs_N_Lott_v_University_of_Leicester_2601796_2020_rule_21.pdf
Our HR policies and processes look good on paper. What the Evans tribunal found is that there is an institutional mindset of subverting them, from the Vice-Chancellor down.
There’s a well established genre of externally-led reviews following findings of this kind. The South Wales Fire and Rescue Service review of 2023 by Fenella Morris KC is a gold standard example. An independently appointed panel, analysis of seven years worth of historical complaints, engagement with the unions and publication in full. It wasn’t even triggered by a lost tribunal case, but by an ITV news report.
Here we have a half credible panel, at best, and unambitious terms of reference. Why should Cambridge settle for this much lower bar?
HOW are these people placed in any position where they can judge anyone?
There seems to be a remarkably consistent pattern to their CVs. Obtain a mediocre degree in a non-STEM subject — history, sociology, German — or leave school at 16.
Then, very early in adult life, cross the invisible membrane separating people who actually do things in the real world — building, teaching, caring, discovering, finding things out through difficult research — from the people who manage the people who do things.
Enter the world of guidelines, HR, communications, coaching, strategy and business school.
Then spend decades becoming extraordinarily proficient at meetings. Master the management vocabulary. Code-switch whenever management theories change. Network relentlessly. Never say anything genuinely dangerous. Never offend anyone who might be useful.
And, year by year, rise from one meaningless job to a slightly grander meaningless job, until eventually you become one of the Great and Good of the Chatterati — and are invited to pass judgement on people whose achievements you would never be remotely capable of matching.
There was a time when Cambridge was administered largely by people drawn from the real world of doing: people who had pushed back the boundaries of human knowledge through intelligence, originality and tenacity; people who had excelled academically in exceptionally difficult disciplines; people who had actually discovered, written, built or thought something of consequence.
They acquired authority because they had achieved something.
We appear to have replaced that principle with an entire professional caste whose principal expertise is administration itself.
And now the administrators judge the scholars.
How on earth did Cambridge University allow this inversion to happen?
What the hell does ‘non-STEM’ have to do with anything. Some of the most idiotic analysis and cluelessness about history and politics I have seen, routinely, comes from STEM people. Famously ignorant about anything beyond STEM.
Only 6 out of the 650 MPs have STEM background. Virtually all of the rest are graduates in soft essay subjects. That is why we haven’t been able to build or create anything for 30 years.
Unhappily, one of the 6 is Lucy Powell (chemistry) — Secretary of State for Education.
Why don’t you peel off and make your own STEM university of bigots?
No wonder 21 group has almost no adherents in the humanities. We see you for what you are.
As an appreciative long-term reader and someone firmly in the humanities, I think now might be a good time to remind everyone that STEM vs humanities, left vs right, or any other binary configuration, is perhaps less important than remembering that many of us are all working towards the same goals: transparency, fairness and accountability.
I agree. As a long-term contributor and someone with a background in both STEM and the Humanities at Cambridge, I have encountered both positive and negative aspects in each domain. My personal priority is to expose the University’s culture of cover-ups and, as Anonymous stressed, to help foster greater transparency, fairness, and accountability within the institution.
This is not true. We are helping a number of people in the humanities departments.
Also worth emphasising the importance of crossing the other divide: academics & administrators
Administrators can also be unfairly dismissed, or victims of false allegations, or subjected to lengthy HR investigations
We have supported administrators at Cambridge, as well as academics. We all have an interest in fairness & transparency
Then stop the Humanities bashing on here. I promise you a great number of people in the humanities find 21 Group dodgy not least due to the bashing of their fields and of DEI. I am one of the few who engages.
Nobody is doubting your ‘helping’, or at least, no one is challenging your claim. However, there is a HUGE amount of humanities bashing here & Freeze Peach or not, it’s not helpful to a unified front. I do note that the racism has come down considerably in recent weeks but who knows when it might resurface. You’re also allowing people to dox despite poor edits that do nothing.
There have been some discussions about a mass exit from West Cambridge and if a new setup at Imperial would be possible. Only preliminary but that such talk would occur should make the University think. The center needs to realise quite how large the disillusionment and upset in the physical sciences is. The debate led by Enough of STEM vs non-STEM is not really the point since there are many in humanities who care deeply about the University – but there is a vocal minority who seem to think it a game to do as much damage to STEM subjects as possible and this grouping is represented on the Council and seems to have traction with the PVCs and certainly the VC
Out of the frying pan…?
I think we all see Enough! for who she is.
This is nonsense
Do you really think you can speak for all of humanities?
I don’t understand why you think it’s “bigoted” to wish for a slightly different representation? Is it so reprehensible to express a wish that there is at least one numerate and grounded engineer or mathematician involved in running University? 30:70 would be fine. 1:99 is not. When I arrived in Cambridge, the VC was a very accomplished engineer and Fellow if the Royal Society. Why can’t we aspire to this kind of leadership again? Why is it “bigotry’ to express an aspiration for a wider range of talent in those who govern us? Why should we tolerate the mediocrity we are offered?
“Some of the most idiotic analysis and cluelessness about history and politics I have seen, routinely, comes from STEM people”
There is an old adage that academics study the thing in life that is most confusing for them, even when it is perfectly intuitive to everyone else.
Some of the worst personal investment decisions are made by economists, the worst acts of management by business school professors, and I dare say that colleagues with the weakest insight into personality and behaviour are psychologists (one may include SBC and our VC in this list). Many sociologists I know have a habit of annoying everyone they meet and then ending up with a narrow friendship circle.
This is not a coincidence, it is what draws people to study a given domain – the total fascination with something a person utterly struggles to comprehend, and eventually, intellectualise it to death.
Does this old adage extend to scholars of anglophone literature(s) or [REDACTED] I wonder?
Hello, Cambridge’s professor of postcolonial studies and anglophone literature(s).
You have something to say to me, I believe, Mr Brave Anonymous? Do let it out, you’ll feel better.
I would say the odds of the most idiotic historical analysis ever having come out of a historian are quite high. Historians have more history information to play with, there are more errors to make in a more complex historical analysis & a higher probability of making unusual errors (the type that defy common sense) it wouldn’t be possible for people playing with less history information to make. If there is a glut of new theories/techniques/information in a field, experts in that field can start making unusual errors – get more complex analysis wrong – and/or significant breakthroughs – get more complex analysis right – it can be a challenge to maintain trust in a subject when then pace of discovery of new information in a subject is high.
Imagine the following experiment. 1000 AI agents are born, and given the goal of publishing articles in humanities journals. At the end of each year, the most prolific survive; the rest are killed and replaced by new AIs. In order to have their articles accepted for publication, they must contribute a novel insight; anything that has been argued before will be rejected.
Several years in, the AIs encounter a challenge. The obvious insights – e.g. early twentieth century communist thought and the works of Bertolt Brecht – have all been mined. In order to survive, the AIs realise that they must develop ever more stretched and “novel” insights in a field of knowledge in which all substantive facts have already been published.
The hapless AIs who insist on literal truth – understanding literature for its original intent – are quickly killed each time.
Instead those that survive the following rounds do so through esotericism, advancing ideas that – though either meaningless or substantively false – can be cleverly argued. One set of AIs moves on to transgenderism in the works of Bertolt Brecht, another to subliminal discursive agency in the works of Bertolt Brecht.
A few rounds later, the AIs find that even this is not enough to guarantee survival. They must develop even more sophisticated methods.
So one set of AIs sets up its own niche journal that is closely gated, into which publication depends upon replication of an obscure terminological pattern known only to members of the group. Another sets up a journal based around the identity of that set of AIs (the “Journal on OpenAI Studies and Literature”). Another sets up a message board with the journal editors and offers inducements for their articles to be prioritised for publication.
Eventually one set of AIs manages to crack the system settings, and redefines the parameters for survival to include non-academic achievements such as promoting certain types of AI model and public engagement. The next round of AIs has abandoned research entirely, set up social media accounts, and is engaged entirely in internal politics to curry favour among the models that control the design prompt.
This experiment can be replicated on any server.
This experiment reminds me of this recent podcast about Cambridge:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aUQnHA4dN2A
“In the week that brought us the news conclusively that Cambridge University will not, in fact, investigate how the serial fantasist Jason Arday came to be appointed a Professor in its education department, but will instead focus on the soapy question of whether he was offered sufficient “support” after being exposed, I’ve been speaking to a man who has seen up close the degradation of our higher education system”
The AI setup you describe is exactly how he describes the decay of modern academia in the second half.
You can call it CP Snow University of Fools, to go with your ship.
There has been a slow drip-drip exodus of talent for years -a collective move to another institution would really be a jolt to the system!
The slow erosion of the talent base at Cambridge has certainly been happening. The only way a sudden mass exodus could happen is if the money goes first.
A large funder could lose confidence in Cambridge’s governance. They wouldn’t announce it as such, but a particularly large centre or facility not having its funded renewed at Cambridge and moving elsewhere is very likely.
I believe that central government is still keen on national institutes such as the Turing and Crick. The big money is now coming from organisations such as ARIA and Convergent Research. A major philanthropist could found the Cambridge equivalent of the Ellison Institute in Oxford, completely independent of the University. This would enable whole research groups to stay in the city, get paid more and suddenly be free of the HR/Legal/Research Office meat grinder.
Cambridge is also particularly vulnerable to academics who’ve had enough of the University to leave with their IP, start a company, or be absorbed by the R&D arm of a multinational. Again, they get to stay here, be paid more and be free to pursue their research in relative freedom.
For the disaffected and disillusioned and those ground down by endless short term contracts, there are options.
Recommend the CP Snow novel, ‘The Affair’ , which is on the unusual topic for a novel of scientific fraud.
We are, allegedly, a “community of scholars”. Does any of the panel members have any experience of the primary purpose of a University, postgraduate research? How many PhDs do they have between them? How many have observed University culture from the perspective of a researcher or academic?
Many would appear to represent that external managerial non-academic culture which has caused so many problems to universities over the past few decades.
It might soon be time for a Discussion on a Topic of Concern.
Riordan presumably had some PhD students long ago when he was at Lecturer in German at Swansea, then Professor of German at Newcastle University.
Discussion on Topic of Concern is great idea
This is a complete humiliation for victims of serious abuse at Cambridge University. Complete bullshit. What is necessary is to address the culture of cover up and to sack incompetent and dishonest people.
“University strengthens wellbeing support for staff
Hanna Weibye
Internal Communications Manager
3 min read
Enhanced counselling support, listening sessions for neurodivergent and Black staff, and a new staff support website have been put in place ahead of the new academic year.
The University is conscious that some staff are starting the academic year following an extremely difficult summer period. We wanted all colleagues to be aware of the various wellbeing services that are currently available, as well as to explain how to access support in the future.
Counselling
Colleagues who wish to access counselling services are encouraged in the first instance to contact the Staff Counselling Centre (SCC). An overview of the centre, who it is for and what to expect is available on its website, as is an online registration form. All sessions are confidential and the SCC expects to offer an initial consultation within one to two weeks. Staff employed by the SCC are accredited counsellors or psychotherapists with additional training in neuro-affirmative, trauma-informed and culturally responsive practices.
Although not intended to be a replacement for the support provided by the SCC, confidential external counselling (up to six sessions face-to-face, online or by telephone) is also now available to staff via the University’s Employee Assistance Programme (EAP). For more information on the EAP, and how to access the service, visit the HR Division’s website.
The EAP also offers other forms of support relating to personal and work-related issues. It is an additional service to the core services offered by the SSC, Staff Wellbeing Team, Occupational Health Team and Sport Service.
Listening sessions for neurodivergent staff
The University is offering a series of sessions for neurodivergent staff following recent events and media coverage relating to neurodivergence. These include the following sessions: listening (group and 1:1 format); reflective; group coaching and mentoring; and 1:1 coaching and mentoring.
This programme will provide opportunities for neurodivergent colleagues to share experiences, reflect with others and access supportive spaces and connections with colleagues who may have had similar experiences. They will be facilitated by the Business Disability Forum, an external and independent organisation with expertise in disability and neurodiversity.
The sessions will run from early October to December 2026. Further information, including details on how to sign up, is available on the ED&I webpages.
Listening sessions for Black staff
The University will also run an identical programme of listening sessions for colleagues of African heritage, Caribbean heritage or other Black backgrounds. These will be facilitated by Onvero, an independent external organisation. Visit the ED&I webpages to find out more and sign up.
Separately, members of the Senior Black Leaders Group, which advocates equity for Black academic and professional services staff within the University, can be contacted confidentially by Black staff. For further information, see the group’s statement on the Staff Hub.
Wellbeing events and Active Staff Programme
The University provides a range of events and programmes to support mental and physical wellbeing, including mental health awareness training, menopause support, mindfulness sessions, sports and exercise classes, and health checks. Explore this term’s events on the wellbeing calendar.
Accessing staff support services and information on wellbeing
The University has created a new website (www.staffsupport.cam.ac.uk) to make it easier to find information about the many staff support services on offer across the University.”
Ask folks working in Occupational Health or Counselling Services at the university and they’ll say many of the people seeking help have been having trouble with HR
Can confirm. Many counselling staff are deeply conflicted about being used as the only space where victims can talk about what has happened and yet are completely powerless to do anything to fix it.
This is the same bullshit. Nothing will change and the clock is ticking to the next staff suicide.
A new website. Listening sessions. Great. Blatant wellbeing washing.
It’s terrible to think that the counselling service are being used as the containment vessel, a safety valve, for institutional harm the University won’t otherwise acknowledge.
As one Cambridge University Counsellor told me: “offering you counselling while you are working in these conditions is like trying to perform surgery on a patient while they are still being repeatedly stabbed”
And the next staff suicide, like most of the previous ones, will be well covered up. The victim will not even be a statistic.
What happened to the “Lego play sessions”? Our infantalisation isn’t complete without it
In the worst case scenario – organisational work-related stress regulation is very far out of bounds in relation to a person i.e. an organisation is generating significant abnormal work-related stressors for a person – survival depends on being able to reason with the level of precision that would be expected of a competent barrister reasoning a criminal case. If it’s an article 2 ECHR reasonable adjustments situation, the level of precision of the reasoning required to reason through any reasonable adjustments with an organisation is a higher level – reasoning precision typically found in criminal cases – as compared to the level of precision of the reasoning required to reason through any reasonable adjustments with an organisation in a more standard case where equality legislation is being applied – i.e. reasoning precision typically found in a civil case. The ability to reason at the level of precision required to reason in a criminal case in a court – that is a survival skill. The ability to get a judge to listen if an organisation and/or a regulator reaches a stage where it cannot be reasoned with in an article 2 ECHR reasonable adjustments situation – that is the basis of survival.
Thanks to Deborah Prentice, the University is never out of the news
https://www.timeshighereducation.com/news/cambridge-hr-review-panel-unbalanced-critics-fear
Seems the press are following the 21 Group blog rather closely
Jack Grove is another person who deserves formal apologies from the University, namely via the Vice-Chancellor directly. However, I have the feeling that Professor Prentice does not know what that means as I do not understand what else is necessary for her to apologize.
Perfectly possible for a Vice Chancellor to apologise
The Vice Chancellor of the Open University, Tim Blackman, did after OU lost an Employment Tribunal against Prof Jo Phoenix
And Blackman did not even give evidence at the Tribunal, far less evidence that was not believed
Prentice needs to apologise for the multiple disasters of the Summer.
Full link here https://www.open.ac.uk/blogs/news/around-ou/ou-speaks-out/a-statement-from-professor-tim-blackman-vice-chancellor-of-the-open-university-regarding-the-recent-employment-tribunal-judgment/
Why is the Vice-Chancellor of Cambridge still there?
I can think of three possibilities:
1. She’s being kept on as the patsy — the fall guy.
They know there’s more bad stuff to come, and that eventually someone will have to be sacrificed. Perhaps the time simply isn’t right yet.
2. The mess is actually so bad that nobody else wants the job.
No one knows quite what to do, or how to begin fixing the situation. So she’s been left to muddle through in her own incompetent way because there’s no obvious alternative.
3. She can’t admit that she’s failed.
Her reputation is already in the toilet, and perhaps she’s hoping to retrieve it and deodorise it by staying long enough to superintend the application of whitewash through the various “independent” inquiries.
Maybe it’s a mixture of all three.
But whichever it is, the fact that she’s still there suggests one thing: we’re completely screwed.
I think there’s something of all three going on, but the second one is the worst. It’s not just a vacant VC post that would currently be hard to fill, we also have two PVC vacancies, no Registrary, no CFO (all before the events of this summer), and potentially a real struggle ahead to restructure the senior leadership. What we have is worse than long term vacant posts, it’s a bankruptcy of trust.
There’s also a boring answer, which is that there’s no button anyone can push to remove her. It’s genuinely constitutionally difficult, and deliberately so. “We’re screwed” is too defeatist for my taste though. There are ballots ahead, Discussions to be had, more court cases to come. This is all an argument for turning up, not giving up.
“…and potentially a real struggle ahead to restructure the senior leadership”
It’s like a ship taking on water while all bilge pumps are running. No-one will join
The University needs a refreshing of its entire senior leadership & it may take a year for them to realise this
And just like the Directorship of Cambridge Cancer Centre – too toxic with the CRUK-Cam scandal exposure looming in the horizon
https://crukcambridgecentre.org.uk/news/were-recruiting-new-director-cancer-research-uk-cambridge-centre
The people most prepared to take on senior leadership roles in a sector when it is already in a crisis are those who are in some sense already crisis tainted by having held a senior leadership role in the crisis hit sector. Anyone with an interest in senior leadership positions in a sector already in a crisis who has not already held one is more likely to watch the current group of senior leaders in that sector in a crisis doing the difficult (crisis = critical) learning & plan to live vicariously through the mistakes of others in preparation for taking on senior leadership roles in future.
“How I was Traumatized by Cambridge University”
https://www.instagram.com/drahmedhankir/reel/DeJaBWvtbiG/
I think a lot of us will identify with this.
Congratulations to Dr. Ahmed Hankir for his incredible bravery and courage.
Together, we will overcome.
“For more than a year, I have pursued institutional, regulatory and legal avenues seeking accountability for an experience involving Cambridge University that caused me profound professional, reputational and psychological harm.
I maintain that it was not an accurate account of what happened, it was not the truth.
Throughout this series, I will distinguish clearly between documented facts, allegations made about me and my own experience and interpretation of events. Where I make factual claims, I have documented evidence to substantiate them.
Before speaking publicly, I informed Cambridge University that I intended to make these videos. I provided the university with the substance of what I intended to say and invited it to identify anything it considered factually inaccurate.”
It’s the Cambridge #MeToo moment. There’s surely tales like this stretching back at least the past decade.
Solidarity with Dr Ahmed ❤️
Did he remove the video?
He seems to have deleted it or made it unavailable. What do you think – more legal threats from Carter-Ruck and their ilk?
Almost certainly
So nothing has changed. It is the same old culture of covering up, same old culture of silencing and intimidation – this is the truth behind the spin.
They will keep on doing the same thing hoping for a different result.
It will continue until the senior leadership is sacked. No doubt about that. I should add that I still have not received any letter from Carter-Ruck or their friends, and I have asked the University to send me one if they believe they have any case for defamation against me. I can assure you that I will update you if and when the situation changes.
“Senior academics set out key questions Cambridge must answer over Jason Arday’s death” https://www.theguardian.com/education/2026/oct/06/cambridge-university-academics-jason-arday-death-investigation-inadequate
Two observations. The letter calls for both consequences for individuals and institutional change. One without the other isn’t enough. Secondly, it’s addressed to the Chancellor. This signals a loss of confidence in the senior leadership to hold itself to account. In particular, he is the one person constitutionally able to act on a failure of leadership of the VC.
Yes, the address to the Chancellor is pointed. Quite astonishing that the letter doesn’t have more signatories seeing as so many have been whingeing about accountability and management culpability.
“More than 40” signatures seems quite a big deal to me. When the University apparently sets expensive lawyers on journalists, there is justifiable fear in speaking up with a critical voice and attaching your name to it.
It’s inevitable that the people willing to take a risk to their careers will be the more senior academics, who are better protected by Statute. Many more people will privately share their thinking. If my recent conversations with colleagues are anything to go by, there is an even wider constituency that’s aware of a black cloud hanging over the University that must be dealt with, without understanding the details.
Especially so, I would argue, as many of us were not even aware of this letter until seeing it in The Guardian. I am certain it could have attracted hundreds of signatories very easily.
We did try. Those hundreds were nowhere to be seen but perhaps Old Schools Refugee is right, people nervous.
@Enough!
As someone who experienced severe abuse at Cambridge years ago I want to thank you for helping with that letter. People are all free to post here and that’s the beauty of this forum, it isn’t about agreeing but having a voice because the truth emerges from dialogue, however strained it may be at times.
Sorry you had to endure that.
Could I just ask if it’s allowed on this site to make parody accounts and also try to unmask who a particular post-er is? it’s happening further down this thread and clearly renders it unsafe to post. I don’t personally give a shit but it strikes me as extremely problematic to allow it. We can all get into that game. You do seem to attract some of the worst trolls on the internet, racist and misogynist.
This query specifically for @21group though others are welcome to weigh in.
We don’t approve of doxing. We will edit the post.
We approve of freedom of speech, so if Prof Uju Anya (Carnegie-Mellon) wanted to post “Die first, white man, then ask yourself why I’m dancing”, we defend her right to do so.
(As you may know, Carnegie-Mellon are investigating her social media activities)
I haven’t the foggiest what Uju Anya has to do with this, a rather dodgy insertion of an irrelevant subject.
Actually, I DO know why you’ve raised this peevish non sequitur, and it reflects badly on you. Cambridge management may have a lot of work to do but, boy, so do 21 Group.
We are making the point that Freedom of Speech is important.
So, if someone wishes to criticise Humanities or STEM or 21 Group, they’re free to do so here.
We gave (Prof) Uju Anya as an example because it is ongoing case on X/Twitter at the moment.
I’ll take that with a pinch of salt especially as I had multiple posts deleted. You thought you’d throw in a Black woman and her comments for no very good reason. No one said the humanities can’t be challenged–I do it all the time myself–but it’s a stupid thing to blame Cambridge’s problems on the humanities. As if Borys covered himself in glory.
“… as I had multiple posts deleted“.
This is not true. All deleted posts go into a Deleted folder. There are no deleted posts from you. Posts are only held back if they are very abusive, or will cause us legal problems. Note that we are receiving letters from a lawyer acting on behalf of a professor, so this is a real concern & risk for us.
You are very welcome to post whatever you want, your views are valued
Not under this account. After I complained, they’ve been allowed through. Delighted my views are valued but perhaps you didn’t quite eliminate the doxxing in that post?
There are no deleted posts under the IP address of @Enough! (irrespective of account name).
We have no interest in deleting posts except for the 2 reasons given (abuse or legally dangerous)
For clarification IP addresses are only used for spam filtering, as the site receives many spam comments. IP addresses for approved comments are purged following approval when the cache renews.
If a person plays with words and/or thinking in their communications with others who also play with words and/or thinking in the same way then the person is unlikely to play with trust in relation to others. If a person plays with words and/or thinking in their communications with others who don’t play with words and/or thinking in the same way or in front of others who don’t play with words and/or thinking in the same way – i.e. plays with words and/or thinking in public statements for all to see – then a person is more likely to play with trust in relation to others.
A person is sensitive to others playing with trust in relation to them – whether unintentionally or intentionally – because it is an indication of a risk to the self originating from others that then needs to be evaluated by the self. Others knowing they do not pose a particular risk to a person is not the same as a person knowing others do not pose a particular risk to them & vice versa. Since it is a trust issue a person would need to be able to do an evaluation of risk to the self that is independent of any person playing with trust in relation to them.
A linguist is practiced in knowing the precise meaning of statements & in knowing precisely what a particular statement cannot be taken to mean in ways others who have not engaged in an in-depth study of linguistics are not. A person who has engaged in in-depth study of many different cultures will know many different ways have been found to mourn the loss of a loved – knowledge others may not yet have acquired.
“You do seem to attract some of the worst trolls on the internet, racist and misogynist”
Do you have any evidence for that? Last time I checked some key concerns featured on this site included standing up against the bullying of women in science, ending sexual harassment and assault, and exposing racial discrimination and the recent court cases at Oxbridge (including Wyn’s) were all about those issues. I don’t know what more you want from this forum honestly!
Yes, plenty. Multiple attacks on ‘DEI’, on ‘Postcolonial’ etc. The word ‘American queen’ is both xenophobic and misogynist. Prentices passport and gender have nothing to do with her failures. Those are but random examples. But you can do the work of going and reading past posts yourself, I am sure. I am not your research assistant to my grave sadness. Have a gorgeous day!
That said, since I started calling it out, the levels have come down. Maybe others should have been doing it too.
I’m a minority academic and I don’t think it is racist to question how EDI is being implemented. I’m not American so I can’t speak to whether anyone is offended by that expression but I think it started as a reference to her annual Christmas videos (and their similarity to the King’s – and formerly the Queen’s) Royal Christmas Message.
Reform clear James Orr 😉
Archived here
https://archive.is/yoSpE
I could not have access to that archive but found this:
https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2026/oct/07/reform-clears-officials-breaking-party-funding-laws-despite-police-investigation
Luckily, we can still rely on Cambridge University to ensure justice in this case. Looking forward to hearing the outcome of their investigation!
Probably the criminal investigation into the breaking of electoral law is most likely to cause problems for Orr!
Internal Cambridge investigations will work they way they always do — nothing to see here 😉
“nothing to see here”
That was the favourite phrase of Kamal Munir 😅
Proof if any were ever required that “self-investigation” only produces a whitewash – never justice or accountability
I think one of the main barriers to higher levels of self regulation in academia is that there are currently multiple significant systemic problems operating simultaneously in academia. Any of these systemic problems alone or any combination of these systemic problems could come into play to complicate the situation of any person in academia making an overall analysis of the situation more mentally taxing & increasing the mental effort required to determine effective self-regulation in that situation.
If a case has attracted significant pubic attention – I.e. involves a high profile person and/or a high profile systemic issue – this increases the pressure to scrutinise the particular situation a person has found themselves in. There is then an increased pressure to understand the situation of the person in greater depth, there is also increased pressure to examine any systemic factors at play in the situation in greater depth. There is an increased potential to introduce distortions in relation to a person and/or in relation to a systemic issue – positive or negative – by over or under attributing fault to the system for the existence of an ongoing situation corresponding to under or over attributing fault to the person for the existence of an ongoing situation.
If you take a high profile case – e.g James Orr in relation to Cambridge University – & break it down into its component elements it becomes clear some of the elements of the case are less particular to the case of James Orr i.e. could have arisen in the case of any academic & some of the elements of the case are more particular to the case of James Orr i.e. could not have arisen in the case of most other academics or possibly any other academic.
Generally the elements of a case that could have arisen in the case of any academic should be the most straightforward/least contentious elements of a case to analyse but because of the current state of academia – multiple significant systemic problems operating simultaneously – even these elements of a case can now also be non-trivial to analyse & a significant potential source of disagreement between those analysing a case & evaluating the seriousness of the ongoing situation.
One of the elements of the James Orr case that could have arisen in the case of any academic is the element of regulation of mental pressure and/or workload in relation to a PhD student during the course of a PhD. This element can show up as statements of this type – bullying, negligence, excessive and unreasonable demands – in a dispute between a PhD student & a PhD supervisor. There is potentially a problem with supervisory mental pressure/workload regulation in relation to a PhD student and/or a problem with student mental pressure/workload regulation in relation to their own self in the context of the constraints of a particular ongoing PhD. The higher the overall pressure of an academic environment the greater the overall challenge it is to regulate mental pressure/workload in that academic environment & also the overall challenge to correct any problems with the regulation of mental pressure/workload regulation in that academic environment.
If a PhD supervisor is under highly variable mental pressure and/or has a highly variable workload – e.g. is juggling multiple roles a subset of which have pressures that can vary significantly & rapidly over time – there is the potential to transmit highly variable pressure to any PhD student being supervised – cycles of more or less supervisory attention, cycles of more or less scrutiny of academic work & feedback on academic progress, cycles of more or less pressure to deliver academic work.
People can differ in their capacity to cope with high variations in mental pressure and/or workload when engaging in academic work something which is distinct from a person having a different overall capacity of produce academic work to a high academic standard. Some people can work in bursts in response to rapid & significant variations in their own internal pressure. Some people can also work in bursts in response to rapid & significant variations in external pressure being placed on them by others. Some people produce their best academic work when working at a steady pace under fairly constant pressure & find it difficult to work in bursts in response to rapid & significant variations in internal or external pressure.
An analysis of this element of the case points to a potential gap in understanding of the factors that can impact the overall probability of a breakdown of a PhD supervisor-student relationship and/or a discontinuation of a PhD degree. It’s not clear this is something universities have a good understanding of in relation to PhD students & academics new to PhD supervision – effective regulation of mental pressure and/or workload : regulation in relation to the self, regulation in relation to others, the impact of a mismatch in regulation between people in a supervisor-student relationship, dynamic situational regulation during the course of a degree.
Big scandals are coming. Brace for impact.
Fibonacci, sssssh it is confidential! 😂
Have you been in a coma for six months? 🙃
It is high time for the HR murderers to answer the public for their crimes.
I hope it is what I think it is.
I am told that the name I am known for is somehow offensive. None of the sort:
1- I am American and very proud of it! I hail from the USofA.
2- I am treated like a Queen:
● I read speeches to the cameras that I don’t write.
● I sign letters that I don’t draft.
● I leave on a large mansion that I don’t pay.
● All my living expenses are paid for.
● I receive a modest stipend that fits my stature (550k per year is frankly cheap)
Why is all of the above offensive I wonder. It is all true.
Cumbersome, slow — its paddlewheel propulsion means leisurely drifting rather than getting anywhere quickly
A perfect name.
Dear American Queen,
Thank you for your enlightening clarification. Some people think that there is still hope for you, but I disagree, and I would like to ask you a few questions, if I may. I understand that you were recently involved in a major employment tribunal case concerning whistleblowing and that your conduct raises fundamental questions about institutional accountability. How could you claim to have been personally involved in drafting a letter that the tribunal found you had not written, while also claiming that complaints had been investigated without being able to establish who had investigated them? Do you understand the issue? The concern is not merely that your evidence was rejected, but that you appeared to endorse institutional decisions without sufficient independent scrutiny, while subsequently giving an account of your involvement that the tribunal did not accept. Please clarify, if you can.
No, American Queen is a great moniker! Keep going. That which we call a Queen would smell just as bad by any other name.
Who is the power behind the throne?
“As I imagined standing here before you in my cassock, gown and bands, looking for all the world like a 19th century PARSON delivering the weekly sermon, I wanted to choose a topic that was both timely and timeless: something that speaks to our moment but also to the current shape and direction of the University (…) The topic I landed on finally is change.”
Somehow reminded of this introductory class joke at Cambridge…
https://www.kellnerfoundation.cz/en/universities/news/how-many-cambridge-professors-does-it-take-to-change-a-lightbulb
How many apologies have been delivered so far?
“Medics allege ‘toxic culture’ at under-fire Addenbrooke’s Hospital”
https://www.itv.com/news/anglia/2026-10-06/medics-allege-toxic-culture-at-under-fire-hospital
They should ask the University’s senior leadership for some help. After all, they have been “reflecting” on the events of this past summer, so I would have thought they’d be keen to demonstrate that they’ve learned something.
Alternatively, we could just appoint the $500,000 a year CEO of Cambridge University Hospitals at the heart of this scandal to another overpaid consultancy role at Cambridge, and put out a press release celebrating ourselves for it.
https://www.cam.ac.uk/news/roland-sinker-cbe-to-develop-university-roadmap-for-inclusive-innovation-and-growth-in-cambridge
“Professor Prentice said:
“Cambridge is at a pivotal moment. The Government’s recent announcements of major investment in Cambridge highlight both the national importance of our innovation ecosystem and the expectations upon us to deliver. We have already made extraordinary contributions, producing education, research, spinouts, and life-changing technologies, services and treatments that add £30 billion to the UK economy every year. Our ambitions are to go further still.”
I wonder who still believes her word. Go further still…
Didn’t Burnham shift the funding focus to the North instead?
They’ll have to cut money from somewhere, especially to fund the new £1bn commitment to the North. Most likely they’ll keep saying they still support Reeves’ Oxbridge corridor boondoggle, while secretly slowpedalling the rail implementation timeline and snipping away at the housing and new town planning.
The government has to take back the power to self govern before self governance is no longer possible. People leave states that have lost the ability to self govern to seek asylum in states that have retained the ability to self govern.
It is critical to self govern in relation to meeting the needs being generated by external failures in self governance to prevent a situation arising where a surge in the needs being generated by external failures in self governance & in the activity demanded to meet those needs triggers an internal failure in self governance. That end result would mean self governance failure propagation from one self governing region to another self governing region & an increasing number of regions generating an increasing amount of needs as a result of failures in self governance for a decreasing number number of self governing regions that remain in a self governing state.
Any obligation to meet the needs being generated by external self governance failures does not extend to the point of an internal self governance failure.
This is a basic self governance principle irrespective of how much risk a self governing region is prepared to take on to meet the needs being generated by external failures in self governance & therefore how much reciprocal risk it could expect other self governing regions to take on in respect of its citizens should it experience a similar type of failure of self governance. A country should not get to a critical self governance point – where it’s make or break for its internal self governance – and not have full control over its self governance.
What is the time line for the reviews? When are they collecting evidence?