The last time a Cambridge Vice-Chancellor was deprived of office was on 7 May 1687.
John Peachell had refused to comply with James II’s order to award an MA degree to the Catholic monk Alban Francis without requiring the customary religious oaths. Cambridge’s Senate resisted the royal demand, maintaining that the University was bound by its statutes.
Peachell was summoned before the Ecclesiastical Commission, presided over by Lord Chancellor Judge Jeffreys, and formally deprived of the Vice-Chancellorship. Isaac Newton, then a fellow of Trinity College, was among the University’s representatives involved in the dispute and accompanied the delegation to London. He thus found himself among those resisting the King’s attempt to override the University’s requirements. Peachell was also suspended from his Mastership of Magdalene College, although he was restored to that position in October 1688; he never regained the Vice Chancellorship.
Today Deborah Prentice gives her formal annual Vice-Chancellor’s Address to the University.
(Image is text of Keynes Ms. 123, King’s College, Cambridge, UK, published online by the Newton Project )
It is unlikely that the Vice-Chancellor will announce that she is stepping down, especially after all the success she had this past year, during which she faced the problems head-on as a good leader:
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cy9wzr5545yo
Optimistic perhaps, but we hope she can fix some of the problems before stepping down.
Prof Deborah Prentice is not the first Vice Chancellor to be criticised in an Employment Tribunal judgment.
The VC of the Open University, Prof Tim Blackman, was criticised in 2024 in the Prof Jo Phoenix case.
Prof Tim Blackman apologised
https://www.open.ac.uk/blogs/news/around-ou/ou-speaks-out/a-statement-from-professor-tim-blackman-vice-chancellor-of-the-open-university-regarding-the-recent-employment-tribunal-judgment/
No apology has yet been issued by Deborah Prentice
We should add Tim Blackman did not appear at the Tribunal — unlike Deborah Prentice.
However his apology was unequivocal: “In several areas we fell very short. We apologise unreservedly to Professor Phoenix for the hurt and distress this has caused.”
As the 21 Group knows, other major cases were running in parallel with the Whistleblowing Tribunal case. Not only did the VC not apologise in relation to this specific case, in which she was directly involved, but she is also aware that the same malpractices are still occurring in other cases and is doing nothing to prevent further damage to either the people involved or the institution for which she is responsible.
I have a feeling that later today she will talk about the “lessons” that “we” have to learn, while these malpractices continue on her watch even as she speaks.
If she is going to apologize for all the malpractices today, it will be a lengthy speech 😉
If she announces that the heads of HR will be having their next annual performance review via live broadcast open session — with the audience able to send in their questions — then that should do the trick.
We would hope that the planned HR review will allow members of the University to submit evidence
The Terms of Reference are yet to be published
Including heads of HR who are leaving! 😊
https://www.cam.ac.uk/jobs/head-of-hr-school-of-clinical-medicine-ah51071
In the meanwhile at College headed by Prof Teflon 1.5 hour-long inclusivity training sessions are mandatory for all undergrads. Go figure…
Interesting. I read recently this post about Caius College, headed by Professor Richard Gilbertson, a Senior Group Leader at the CRUK Cambridge Institute, which mentions something along those lines:
https://x.com/mother_of_rome/status/2104825300232094179
TERF nonsense, irrelevant to the matter at hand.
I fail to see what the Tribunal judgement –or indeed any of these failed managers–has to do with inclusivity.
It is not enough to bully people and to make it clear that they are valueless. One should also force them to attend courses on how they should respect and value each other, whilst bullying them and making it clear that they are not valued.
We want our alumni to be successful, and then to donate money. To me successful, one must be nasty. Too many young, naive, students are infected with an unnatural niceness and goodness of heart. By coercing them to waste hours on being told to be nice, one can hope to undo this damage, and make them detest niceness. They will soon see the contrast between the goody no-hopers in these training sessions, and distinguished people of power like us. They will work out what behaviour is rewarded.
We must take care to ensure that we are not letting standards slip by bullying only minorities when we could have a broad, inclusive, campaign of bullying and condescension.
These kind of courses alway seem less about improving good practice than demonstrating that ‘something has been done’
Department X has a problem with bullying, so HR organise a training course for the department on ‘How not to Bully’.
Now they can say ‘something has been done’.
I think there can be problems achieving a legitimate aim – stop [x] – if the legitimate aim itself is not properly constrained. If the aim is to train every person to stop [x] in relation to others & there are no additional constraints being applied while working towards that aim to also stop [x] in relation to the self by others and to stop [x] in relation to the self by the self then the aim itself could be an unbalanced aim and it’s unclear whether an unbalanced aim can be achieved.
If a person is being trained to stop [x] in relation to others but not to also stop [x] in relation to their own self by others and not to also stop [x] in relation to their own self by their own self then this could result in a person stopping [x] in relation to others at the expense of accepting [x] in relation to themselves by others or accepting [x] in relation to their own self by their own self. The training could achieve the aim of training every person to stop [x] in relation to others without ever achieving the overall aim of stopping [x] because the legitimate aim of the training is not properly constrained.
Do you remember the old, paper, “Staff Guide to Bullying” booklet. Or the Departmental Secretary (now retired) who was said to have read it carefully, and to have used every technique it described? Sending barons on anti-bullying courses can have a negative outcome.
“To me successful, one must be nasty.”
To be successful – one must become resistant to high levels of nastiness from others without resorting to high levels of nastiness towards others. To be inclusive – one must become resistant to others applying high exclusionary forces to you without resorting to applying high exclusionary forces to others. To hold on to your own value – one must become resistant to the attempts of others to devalue you without resorting to attempts to devalue others.
A person/group with an aim [x] – undertaking activities to achieve aim [x] – can experience high resistance from others for reasons that have nothing to do with whether others accept aim [x] to be a legitimate aim or not. If in the course of a person/group undertaking activities to achieve a legitimate aim [x] inaccurate information is been generated & propagated in an environment then high resistance from others can be experienced irrespective of whether those others accept aim [x] to be a legitimate aim or not. People will resist the propagation of inaccurate information in an environment in proportion to both the level of inaccuracy of the information itself and the potential impact on peoples lives of the propagation of information of that particular type with that level of inaccuracy in an environment.
People in universities have a high sensitivity to the accuracy of information i.e. are highly sensitive to the accuracy of information in general & also have highly-specialised sensitivity to the accuracy of particular types of information due to subject specialisation e.g. statements as to the legality of something. There will be people in universities who are highly resistant to the propagation of inaccurate information in a university environment.
A person could be highly sensitive to the accuracy of information in general & highly resistant to the propagation of inaccurate information in an environment & this could happen to be evident in a training session run by a person/group with a legitimate aim [x] in the form of a person being highly resistant to some of the information being presented to them in a training session. It cannot automatically be assumed by the person/group with a legitimate aim [x] that a person they are experiencing high resistance from in a training session does not accept the legitimacy of aim [x], is less able to make a significant contribution to the achievement of aim [x] or is a barrier to achieving aim [x].
If in the course of a person/group trying to achieve a legitimate aim [x] by undertaking activities to achieve aim [x] inaccurate information is being generated & propagated in an environment then this will not increase the overall probability of aim [x] being achieved in reality. This may increase the chances of people being lead to believe a legitimate aim [x] has been achieved when aim [x] has not in reality been achieved but it won’t increase the chances of aim [x] being achieved in reality.
This speech is going to be the dictionary definition of awkward… I can already hear the sound of nails screeching on a blackboard in the background
Why isn’t it online yet?
Last year it wasn’t published until the following day. If anyone was in the room this morning, we’re all waiting to hear from you!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=afMRn_sf-mQ
Interesting speech; did not dodge the elephants in the room. As always, ChatGPT has the best transcript analysis (pasted here):
I would read the speech as containing a potentially quite significant institutional reform argument, but not yet an accountability argument.
Its implicit proposition is approximately:
Cambridge’s traditions and academic mission are worth preserving, but its governance and administrative machinery cannot be treated as sacrosanct. When things go seriously wrong, the University must examine itself, use genuinely external expertise, learn from failure, and modernise its systems.
That is a coherent position.
But after the tribunal judgement, there is an important unresolved second proposition:
If the machinery failed partly because of decisions made by people at the top of the institution, can those same structures—including the current leadership—credibly determine the scope and consequences of the investigation into that failure?
The speech gives a strong answer to the first question—yes, Cambridge needs to change—but is much less explicit about the second—who should be accountable when Cambridge’s leadership or governance itself is part of what needs examination?
And that distinction is particularly important because the University has now explicitly committed to independent review. The later announced review following Arday’s death is divided into a review of his support and circumstances and a broader institutional-process review, with an external chair and an expert panel envisaged for the latter.
So, if you are assessing Prentice’s speech critically, I would focus less on whether she sounds committed to change and more on whether the institutional mechanisms she describes can satisfy her own standards of independence, transparency, legibility, timeliness and accountability.
That will provide a much sharper test of the speech than simply asking whether she advocates “change.”
Overall, the tone was surprisingly upbeat, with considerable emphasis placed on successes such as philanthropy, Rokos, corporate partnerships, quantum computers.
However, where I had personal knowledge of the issues discussed, the reality often seemed to contradict Prentice’s account. The presentation therefore gave a rose-tinted view of the future, glossing over serious problems and, at times, making claims that did not appear to align with the facts.
Interesting, what issues specifically? Obviously she had to be upbeat, but also in alignment with facts.
To take one example, new software projects (finance, HR) will drive change & make Cambridge more efficient on optimistic timescales
A reasonable inference would be that she’s not being told what’s actually going on with these projects.
Perhaps I need to watch her speech again, but am I right in saying that the Vice-Chancellor talked about the need for change at the University and about how the University should learn from its negative experiences, but failed to tell us what exactly she will change about her own behaviour in light of her own negative experiences as Vice-Chancellor? I wonder whether she thinks her own behaviour has been good.
Quick initial reactions to the speech.
She did name one of the elephants in the room, but then gave a lecture on zoology.
The lecture seemed to be about institutional culture with no reference to its conduct.
Yes, Cambridge is culturally resistant to change. Her advocacy for a new COO was interesting. Did she frame opposition to this as merely resistance to change?
She was found individually at fault during the Evans tribunal, but it’s all collectively our fault and up to us to effect change?
And finally, there was no apology or hint at culpability for the events of the summer, not even on behalf of the institution.
The implicit message seemed to me something like:
1. I am not in charge of this ship. From the moment I arrived people were telling me what to do, what (not) to say. I was put among long-standing insiders who said they knew what was best down to the tiniest details.
2. I need your help through democratic procedures (Regent House) to do anything against these people.
Hmm…. change… the reason there is resistance to that at Cambridge, is that for decades it has been change for the worse: more power to the administration, a bigger administration, more control by a narrow group, more senseless work for the staff on the ground. No one sane objects to changes for the better.
Spot on. If I remember correctly she did talk about that at the start, how the university had expanded its administrative overhead due to regulatory compliance, government, legal changes and so on. But not about how that same machinery has turned against the spirit of compliance (e.g. on safeguarding) towards a system of non-compliance to cover up failures, obstruct common sense decisions by line management, introduce rigidities that prevent decisions being taken or managerial accountability or initiative, and introduce myriad perverse incentives for rent-seeking from consultants or legal advisors.
In fact the machinery has turned against the University’s very raison d’être, to enable teaching and learning, and the advancement of knowledge.
As if an academic turned administrator had to leave behind all academic principles.
Debbie is the disgrace we all know she is. She only cares about her money (550k/year) and has no shame, no honour and no integrity. What did everyone expect! She will not resign. She needs to be kicked out. Wake up people.
The paradox is that she is paid like a CEO, but apparently either does not possess, or does not exert, executive authority. A CEO would have fired people by now, apologised, and proposed a 15-point plan with concrete weekly, monthly, and annual deadlines to right the ship. What we have is spinning things out to independent review, which is fine for someone who is an honorary appointee, but not what you expect from someone on close to a $1m pay package.
She isn’t a CEO.
Absolutely! But of course the oligarchy, Hudson, legal, RO and many HoS and HoD want her to stay because they know what woukd happen to them if she goes. The place stinks like a sewer.
“Call for ‘greater openness to change’ at Cambridge”
As if people could trust the word of a person who engaged in whistleblowing retaliation and did not yet find the time to apolagize:
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cmx2z2d1d5y3o
Whatever the outcome of the Court case, I think Professor Teflon’s real punishment still lies ahead of him at Caius. At least when he was at CRUK/Oncology/School of Clinical Medicine he was surrounded by rational and grounded people with who are all aligned with a post-enlightenment view of rational thought and objective truth. Now he’s moved into a madhouse full of unhinged zealots whose only truth is their truth.
I do not quite understand your point. Could you please elaborate?
Panel to investigate university processes & its terms of reference are announced
https://universityofcambridgecloud.sharepoint.com/sites/StaffHub/SitePages/Independent-review-of-certain-University-processes–terms-of-reference-and-panel-members.aspx?CID=83b24970-9e45-4a64-9bea-2d33b5a0041b
Panel is
The review lead and chair of the panel will be Laura Whyte, a non-executive director with expertise in multi-stakeholder environments and large, dispersed workforces. Laura is a former HR Director of John Lewis and has experience as a Remuneration Committee member in listed, private and charitable sectors. Laura led an independent ‘Respect at Work’ review at HMRC, which was published in 2019.
The other panel members are:
Cindy Butts, the Independent Public Advocate for England and Wales, who is serving in a personal capacity and brings more than 20 years in senior independent roles across policing, criminal justice, Parliament and public life. Cindy has a particular focus on organisational culture, governance, complaints and conduct, inclusivity and institutional accountability. She formerly chaired the Independent Commission for Equity in Cricket and made wide-ranging recommendations for institutional and cultural change.
Mary Curnock Cook CBE, an independent education expert and former Chief Executive of UCAS from 2010 to 2017. Mary maintains a portfolio of non-executive governance roles, serving as Non-Executive Director at Pearson Education, lay Council member at the University of Leicester and Trustee at the Higher Education Policy Institute.
Helen Fairfoul OBE. Helen was Chief Executive of the Universities and Colleges Employers Association from 2012 to 2020, where she led national pay negotiations and advised universities on HR, reward and employment strategy across the sector. She currently serves as an independent governor and Pro-Chancellor of Northumbria University, chairing its Finance and Resources Committee alongside other non-eecutive board roles.
Professor Colin Riordan CBE, the Secretary General and Chief Executive Officer of the Association of Commonwealth Universities. Colin was previously Vice-Chancellor of Cardiff University (2012-2023) and the University of Essex (2007-2012). He currently serves as a lay member of Newcastle University Council and has undertaken numerous board roles including on Universities UK, UCAS and Advance HE.
It is going to be a white wash. Total waste of time. Establishment protecting Establishment.
Looks like a roll call of quango apparatchiks, all representatives of management, no democratic input. Who designed this? They have guaranteed another two years of scandals. This is just like the Post Office “self-investigation” of 2012-15.
It’s worth checking out Laura Whyte’s ‘Respect at Work’ review for HMRC. It’s publicly available in full online, as this report should be.
Reporting just to Council, with a likely redacted summary available more widely, is just not good enough. Laura Whyte may seek useful amendments to the terms of reference, but these are granted at the discretion of one person: the deputy chair of Council.
It doesn’t have to be a whitewash, but the mechanisms for turning it into one are plainly there.
This shows why the HR Grace is still badly needed.
“This shows why the HR Grace is still badly needed.”
Exactly.
The entire process should be under transparent democratic control, not managed by the people who made the mistakes.
There is no diversity of viewpoint — they could have included a trade-unionist, employment lawyer or some rank-and file academics
Their panel members will all think the same way
More news on Orr: https://www.varsity.co.uk/news/32175
Dear Cambridge community and the public in general,
This is the kind of shameful behaviour we have to put up with at this institution:
“In response to a request for comment, a spokesperson for the University of Cambridge said: ‘We have clear policies and processes in place to protect our students and staff. We cannot comment on individual cases because our students and staff have a right to confidentiality.’”
Confidentiality is used to conceal and manipulate information at Cambridge, and the individuals who foster this practice are dishonest and cowardly. They could not care less about students and staff.
”The University of Cambridge said it was “looking into” Orr’s conduct after the Channel 4 investigation. The University has not, however, acknowledged publicly the allegations of internal misconduct made by the FT.’
[…]
‘In response to separate allegations made by the Financial Times, the University stated that it had “no reason to believe that Dr Orr’s external roles have adversely affected his performance of his contractual duties”. One faculty member told Varsity that the University’s statement “just cannot stand up”.’
I’ve never seen anything like this. This is surely a firing offence? Not for elite white men, ofc.
Seeing how much discussion there was here over other acts of possible academic misconduct, quite surprised at the silence on the patently special treatment received by James Orr, coddled by manageriate to all appearances. Not turning up at your own lectures multiple times! Imagine if a ‘DEI hire’ (so-called, in his own words) had done that.
Students have praised the coverage of the Orr case on the 21 Group as better than the FT!
Latest allegations need looking into, but do not seem as serious as the earlier bullying allegations.
By far the most serious thing is the (apparent) attempts to circumvent UK electoral law, which has implications for his integrity & honesty. So if there are criminal charges & convictions, then Orr will have to go, whatever the manageriate want.
@Enough!
Anyone can post here so if you want less silence about Orr all you have to do is add a comment?
Once again AI has the best read on the panel composition:
“What I think is missing:
This is where I would be asking Cambridge some quite pointed questions.
1. A senior employment-law/whistleblowing specialist
The trigger for this review includes an employment tribunal. Yet none of the five, from the biographies provided, is principally an employment lawyer or specialist employment tribunal investigator.
That’s a surprising omission.
The panel should have access to someone who can analyse questions such as:
– protected disclosures;
– detriment/victimisation;
– grievance procedures;
– conflicts between HR advice and managerial decision-making;
– independence of investigations;
– procedural fairness;
– record keeping;
– legal privilege;
– settlement/confidentiality practices;
– governance failures revealed by litigation.
2. Someone who has actually investigated institutional failure
Butts comes closest.
But there is a difference between governance expertise and being an independent investigator who can reconstruct what happened, identify who knew what and when, examine documentary evidence and interview participants.
Given the tribunal findings, I would regard that investigative capacity as essential.
3. An academic voice
This is the omission I find particularly striking.
The problems at Cambridge aren’t simply generic workplace-HR problems. Cambridge is a highly unusual institution with:
– academic freedom;
– tenure/security of employment issues;
– departmental and faculty autonomy;
– colleges;
– elected academics;
– extraordinarily strong informal hierarchies;
– senior academics who may simultaneously have managerial and collegial roles.
None of the biographies you’ve quoted screams “experienced academic who understands the internal power dynamics of universities from the employee side.”
That’s different from having been a vice-chancellor.
4. A staff/whistleblower perspective
There isn’t an obvious representative of the people who actually have to use Cambridge’s grievance and whistleblowing machinery.
That matters enormously.
A review of complaints systems can become a review of whether the paperwork and policies are adequate. But the much harder question is:
Why would a junior academic, researcher, professional-services employee or other member of staff trust the system enough to use it when the person they are complaining about is powerful?
The panel should explicitly address that.”
The panel will do nothing of the sort! The VC that lied at the Tribunal and her management team who also lied are running the show! UCam is a sewer!
I think we need to think maturely about the solution, here, within the confines of the procedures now in place.
In my view, the big issue for the review to be a success will be in it separating what exists “on paper” – which all looks wonderful – from how such procedures (Dignity at Work,HR consultation, SAR, Medical Services, Grievance Investigation) operate in practice. We all know that they do not.
Why? The reality in practice, of which we are all acutely aware, is that the system is rife with conflicts of interest and that the HR Committee, senior HR administrators, and Legal Services are all in touch with one another, and therefore, have the capacity to subvert the entire apparatus of rules and procedures that at present exist. For those in positions of power, medical advisories can be simply ignored, subject access requests redacted or entirely blocked, grievances stonewalled, counter-grievances initiated to shut people down, and staff bullied or harassed out of their roles.
In particular, I have time and time again found that a culture of senior academic confusion and paranoia over prevailing standards has meant a total derogation of academic managerial decisionmaking to HR, and even more especially legal services, whose functional scope has expanded from simply “advising their client on where they stand in upcoming tribunal cases” to “taking decisions over the entire HR, information office, communications, promotions, and line management interactions of the whole university”. But they do this not in line with the university’s mandate, but only in a way that serves their narrow goals (strengthening some hypothetical future legal position at court) ignoring the damage caused to our ability to foster the highest standards in teaching and research.
I have observed it over a long period, and now, needless to say, it has resulted in a quite catastrophic reputational damage for the university in a way that has proven costly to a degree one can barely even quantify at this point. I frankly struggle to calculate the sheer magnitude of the long-term loss we will now experience from furious alumni, perplexed donors, and the puzzlement of government partners and funding agencies at how we are operating, not least of all given that our own research funding capacities have been crippled.
The obvious solution is to put both HR and legal back in their box — including strict firewalls to prevent such conflicts of interest operating. It is also obvious, at this point, that only open, legible accountability is needed to preserve such reforms from lapsing back in the old (that is to say, the current) system. That including reporting on websites such as this, as well as in Varsity and THE — but also more broadly, tolerating a culture of staff speaking openly on social media about their experiences as they are happening. Such openness is not a threat to “confidentiality” that will “embarrass” staff — there should be no embarrassment from people being aware of the routine and ongoing interpersonal disputes that is, of course, already (and has always been) part and parcel of the “gossip” among our respective academic circles. A constant low level of gossip is what helps to resolve matters — what brings people to volunteer as intermediaries to resolve disputes or tap a colleague on the shoulder and ask them to tone things down. Far from a threat, on the contrary this open knowledge is precisely the protection mechanism that ensures matters are responded to in good time by people of good faith, before they escalate in to far more serious embarrassments for university as a whole, as they so clearly have done now.
Cambridge doesn’t need a review any more — you have articulated brilliantly what is going wrong.
I perceive another change.
In the distant past, a lot of the more senior academic-related roles were held by “failed academics” — people who had nearly made it into a full academic career, but not quite. They were empathetic towards academics, but they made mistakes, were branded amateur, and were swept aside.
Now such roles are full of “professionals”. But not good professionals. We pay too little to attract the best from the private sector, so we get those who have failed to make a career in the private sector. Not only are they far from the world-leading standards we claim to expect of our academics, they simply do not have a clue how a University works, or what its culture is, because most of them have zero experience of postgraduate teaching or research.
As merely one example, some years ago the Head of IT in a major Dept told me that he intended to introduce a firewall. This was before they were common, so it sounded like a good proactive approach to security. I was stupid enough to ask what he thought the main purpose of this firewall would be. The response was that it was to prevent staff from browsing porn sites and other dodgy sites during their breaks, and to impose a white-list only policy on which external sites were accessible. He was not considering blocking incoming connections. That might make some sense in a third-rate company, but for a University?
It also neatly encapsulates the idea that academic-related staff exist to police academics and to stop them doing things, not to support them. Far too often I am involved in discussions with support staff which revolve around why you can’t to do something, not how you can be enabled to do something. I do not think this attitude was as common thirty years ago. The result is a lot of distrust between academics and “support” staff. (The same Head of IT above used to refer to academics as “the enemy.”)
“the Head of IT in a major Dept told me that he intended to introduce a firewall…. He was not considering blocking incoming connections”
That is hilarious! Surely almost all incoming STEM undergrads know exactly what a firewall is and could even set up a fairly good one. How the hell was this guy hired in the first place – let alone promoted to “Head of IT”? It is truly “computer says no” territory.
I don’t think this is true of Cambridge VC/PVCs. They are, in fact, failed academics for the most part, at least the ones I know, and more viciously managerial and power-hungry for that. We really don’t need managerial private sector types coming in but we need to redo how universities are governed entirely in more democratic directions.
Agreed. It is not true of Cambridge VCs/PVCs, who are now often (but not always) failed academics. However, increasingly, other institutions appoint professional administrators as PVCs (see Oxford). At Cambridge it is true of senior UAS figures. For instance,
the Registrary post was mostly held by ex-academics until Stephen Fleet retired in 1997. Often it was held by distinguished scholars who understood the University’s democratic norms: e.g., John Keynes, Henry Luard, John Clark, John Taylor, Robert Rattenbury. Now it is held by undistinguished professional administrators who try to subvert those norms.
There’s a strong argument that the decline of Cambridge set in with the appointment of the professional registrary.
Even stronger argument that the out-of-control spending on administration/consultants set in with the appointment of Ms Rampton.
Is it not time for an investigation into that?
The Reporter, 30th Nov 2016, informed us “Following advertisement and a search process supported by recruitment consultants, the Council has decided not to appoint substantively to the office of Registrary at this time. The Council has agreed to appoint Emma Rampton, currently Academic Secretary, as Acting Registrary under Statute C VI 5 for a period of two years with effect from 1 January 2017. This will allow the Vice-Chancellor-Elect to start a new process for the appointment of a permanent Registrary at a time of his own choosing in the first year of his tenure.”
Then, as if by magic, before Toope was even in office, and long before this two-year temporary appointment was due to expire, we were informed by The Reporter of 5th July 2017 “The Council gives notice that, following consultation with the Vice-Chancellor-Elect, it has appointed Emma Machteld Clara Rampton, M.A., Oxford, C.P.E., L.P.C., College of Law, London, Acting Registrary of the University of Cambridge and Fellow of Sidney Sussex College, to the office of Registrary from 1 October 2017.”
I have no idea what happened, but I do know that several people had, by that point, concluded that she would not be the ideal candidate for the permanent appointment. The process was far from transparent, and the first announcement from Council was pretty misleading.
Your diagnosis of institutional capture by HR and Legal and your proposed solution – strict firewalls against conflicts of interest and open, legible accountability – is absolutely correct.
I would just be a little careful about confidentiality. Used in the service of justice, rather than reputation management, it’s what should enable a frightened postdoc or junior administrator to speak up. I think that the success of anonymous blogs and social media commentary is a symptom that has arisen out of desperation. The system is so dysfunctional, this seems to be the only option left.”
In a word, what is missing is collegiality. So many workplace problems can be resolved early once colleagues are aware of a matter and able to step in and do something about it. In Oxbridge of time gone by, there were strong social networks through the colleges that allowed junior staff to find senior mentors, and senior figures to broker a resolution for them at a higher faculty level. That has now largely gone: many people either do not join colleges or attend very rarely, while the work from home culture (very amenable to an academic routine) has thinned out networks even more. The other factor eroding solidarity is compliance paranoia: even when minded to help a struggling colleague, to many people think “will this get me in to trouble?” Shouldn’t they go via our (existent on paper but defunct in practice) grievance procedures instead? Then those fail, legal cases emerge, and the confused colleague is left isolated, alone, and at the mercy of lawyers who control every aspect of their university interaction, in secret and without their awareness.
@Old Schools Refugee, perhaps I misunderstood your comment, and I apologize if I did, but no one should be subjected to enforced confidentiality that is used to manipulate information. In my view, dishonest people should be exposed and publicly embarrassed, and Cambridge University is full of such people. Those who prefer to raise issues in confidence should have that choice. Those who do not should not be forced to do so, particularly when they know how those responsible for addressing concerns actually deal with them.
Cambridge University uses and abuses the “confidentiality” card in its favour, and that needs to stop. I was manipulated through it once, and I will not make the same mistake again. People who comply with this enforced confidentiality—effectively non-judicial gagging—should at least be aware of how the institution uses it against victims.
The “confidentiality” thing never made any sense to me. What are they afraid of? Even on a site like this where people can post anonymously, almost no-one gets named (or is referenced only exceptionally obliquely) until matters have gone public. I do not think readers of this site really had any sense of the shenanigans in Astronomy until it came out at Tribunal (and that is the most frequently referenced scandal here). In a post-MeToo world I find it odd how strong is the tacit norm among students, postdocs and ECRs of respecting the privacy of individual figures at HOH, HOD and HOS level even when they have done some utterly outlandish things.
On collegiality: I agree, and I miss that too. What you describe feels nostalgic, but I wonder if part of the answer is to roll back the number of Teams meetings and increase the capacity of the College system for all categories of staff, making work from home not so attractive after all?
@TheResearcher, apologies to you. I should clarify. I’m not talking about enforced confidentiality, which can be a tool for abuse. When there’s an imbalance of power and seniority, it should be the junior individual’s right to waive, not imposed by the institution. A shield, not a gag.
@Old Schools Refugee, got it. Thanks!
The absence of an academic voice is entirely unsurprising but still shocking, and really encapsulates what this management thinks of the people it supposedly serves.
This whitewash panel is COMPLETELY UNACCEPTABLE. There should be a letter of immediate condemnation and demands for proper accountability to be built in. Unsurprising this has happened but still staggering that they have no sense of shame or responsibility on any of these matters. Grace should not be ruled out either but first it should be condemned immediately.
Agreed. This panel is unacceptable and if it isn’t changed, we should all boycott it
The Grace is the best hope of some accountability
Shenanigans in Astronomy & Confidentiality
It’s worth pointing out that I made repeated attempts to settle with the University before the Tribunal, which would have avoided public exposure of the shenanigans.
The University had already been told in an independent barrister’s Report that they commissioned in 2022 that what I did met the legal threshold for ‘whistleblowing’
The University ignored this, and then went to a 4 week Tribunal with a celebrity barrister to be told the same thing again, and more expensively and publicly. The Vice Chancellor was either not told the true situation, or (if she was) took a huge gamble in testifying.
Apparently, someone in the University really thought they were going to win (as did one of the Directors of the IoA).
This was a huge misjudgment, it has caused untold damage — and someone really should be held accountable.
Reaction to Prentice’s speech — take a look at LinkedIn
https://lnkd.in/p/eU6NYZck
Just 8 comments, most of which are along the lines of “I want to study at Cambridge University”
And so, the summer of scandal ends not with a big bang of reform, but a mere whimper of apathy. The University has 1,368,805 followers on LinkedIn – and yet, somehow, the video manages just 8 comments – ending with these two gems:
Ajayi Igbekele
23h
That is lovely environment… I would love to study in cambridge… It is acedemics of my choice… I can’t wait to study at Cambridge
Andrew Lenton
19h
Still wear funny hats, though.
Clearly the damage is done, and the world has simply stopped listening to whatever Cambridge has to say for itself.
I think it is worse. The conversation on Twitter, Reddit and Facebook remains lively but no-one is listening to the university aby more. They are no longer a participant in the dialogue about themselves.
Students are back in town!
“Staff criticise ‘controversial’ Uni plans to restructure senior administrative offices”
https://www.varsity.co.uk/news/32160
And here:
“University’s review following Professor Arday’s death faces backlash ”
https://www.varsity.co.uk/news/32167
And here:
“Is the Uni ready to talk about rape?”
https://www.varsity.co.uk/features/32149
OSCCA, What a shame:
“My caseworker was a wonderful, kind, gentle, and supportive man. […] but he was working within a broken system. He told me I had different options, but he was frank with me: there was no chance of getting my attacker any real penalty that felt justified.”
Someone should tell this student that OSCCA can expel students when they really want. It is full of dishonest people who pretend they are nice.
A long overdue conversation – well done to Varsity for bringing this forward.